×
Choose Autoship and get MVP Gold for FREE! (That's a $10 Value!)
Explore Autoship
Help
1-888-887-0063
baxter@baxterboo.com
Chat with us!
FAQs
Sign In
Sign In
Create Account
Pet Insurance Quote
Cart
0
Earn up to 10% Rewards back!
Learn More
You have no items in your cart. Start shopping for your best furry friend today!
Shop Now
Shop For Dogs
Food
Dehydrated Food
Dry Food
Food Topper
Freeze-Dried Food
Wet Food
Veterinary Diet
Shop All Food
Treats
Biscuits & Crunchy Treats
Bones, Bully & Natural Chews
Dental Treats
Freeze-Dried Treats
Jerky Treats
Single Ingredient
Soft & Chewy Treats
Specialty
Training Treats
Shop All Treats
Healthcare
Allergy
Anxiety & Calming
Dental Care
Digestive & Urinary Aid
First Aid & Recovery
Herbal Supplements
Hip & Joint Care
Skin & Coat Care
Vitamins/Supplements
Shop All Health
Fashion
Clothes
Coats
Costumes
Dresses
Graphic Tees
Hoodies
Jackets
Pajamas
Sweaters
Funny Shirts
Shirts
Shop All Fashion
Supplies
Boots & Shoes
Cleaning & Waste
Collars
Costumes
Crates, Gates & Pens
Dirty Dogs
Fashion Accessories
Flea & Tick
Goggles
Grooming
Harnesses
Home Goods
Leashes
Medical and Mobility
Outdoor
Ramps & Stairs
Safety
Strollers
Toys
Training & Behavior
Travel & Carriers
Working Dogs
Popular Brands
Shop For Cats
Food
Dehydrated Food
Dry Food
Food Topper
Freeze-Dried Food
Wet Food
Veterinary Diet
Shop All Food
Treats
Catnip & Pet Grass
Crunchy Treats
Food Topper
Freeze-Dried & Dehydrated Treats
Lickable Treats
Soft & Chewy Treats
Shop All Treats
Healthcare
Anxiety & Calming
Dental Care
Digestive & Urinary Aid
Ear Care
Eye Care
First Aid & Recovery
Hip & Joint Care
Skin & Coat Care
Vitamins/Supplements
Shop All Health
Toys
Balls & Chasers
Catnip Toys
Interactive & Electronic Toys
Plush & Mice Toys
Scratchers
Teasers & Wands
Variety Packs
Shop All Toys
Supplies
Accessories
Beds
Bowls & Diners
Bundle
Carriers
Cleaning & Waste
Clothes
Collar Charms
Collars & Leashes
Crates and Cages
Flea & Tick
Furniture
Grooming
Harnesses
Home & Gifts for Lovers
Home Decor
ID Tags
Litter
Pharmacy for Cats
Scratching Posts
Special Occasions
Travel
Pharmacy
Medication
Digestive Health
Heartworm
Pain Relief
Eye and Ear Care
Flea & Tick
Heart Health
Antibiotics
Allergy Relief
Skin Care
Shop All
Veterinary Diet
Purina Pro Plan Veterinary Diets
BLUE Natural Veterinary Diet
Shop All Vet Diet
Health Condition
Anxiety Relief
Brain Health
Digestive Health
Heart Care
Pain Relief
Skin & Coat Health
Brands
Popular Brands
Farm to Pet
ChuckIt
Fancy Feast
Dr. Marty's
Zuke's
Heartgard
Shop All Brands
New Arrivals
🎉 Pre-Black Friday
MVP Rewards
0
Get up to 15% Off your 1st Autoship
learn more
Earn up to 10% Rewards Back Today!
learn more
Same Day Shipping!
Order by 3pm EST
Save 15% on your 1st Autoship
learn more
Shop For Dogs
Boots & Shoes
Cleaning & Waste
Clothes
Collars
Costumes
Crates, Gates & Pens
Dirty Dogs
Fashion Accessories
Flea & Tick
Food
Goggles
Grooming
Harnesses
Healthcare
Home Goods
Leashes
Medical and Mobility
Outdoor
Pharmacy for Dogs
Ramps & Stairs
Safety
Sports Team Gear
Strollers
Toys
Training & Behavior
Travel & Carriers
Treats
Working Dogs
Shop For Cats
Accessories
Beds
Bowls & Diners
Bundle
Carriers
Cleaning & Waste
Clothes
Collar Charms
Collars & Leashes
Crates and Cages
Flea & Tick
Food
Furniture
Grooming
Harnesses
Healthcare
Home & Gifts for Lovers
Home Decor
ID Tags
Litter
Pharmacy for Cats
Scratching Posts
Special Occasions
Toys
Travel
Treats
Pharmacy
Shop By Brand
New Arrivals
🎉 Pre-Black Friday
Weekly Deals
MVP Rewards
Sign In
Create Account
Help
1-888-887-0063
baxter@baxterboo.com
FAQs
Pet Insurance Quote
CATEGORY
Dog Toys
Cat Toys
Brands
Gor Pets
HugSmart Pet
Huxley & Kent
Kittybelles
Lulubelles
Tall Tails
Colors
Green
Pink
Red
White
Yellow
Featured Line
Under The Sea
Gender
Neutral
Lifestage
Adult
Kitten
Puppy
Senior
Materials
Catnip
Corduroy
Mylar Crinkle
Plush
Poly-Filled
Patterns
Fish
Nautical
Pet
Cat
Dog
Seasons
Summer
Home
(5 items)
Plush
Under The Sea
Yellow
$0 - $25
Clear all
Plush
Sort By:
Popular
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
New Items
Name
Discount
Rating
Filter By
Earn
10%
in rewards!
Kittybelles Plush Fish Cat Toy - Rainbow Guppy
Starting at:
$4.99
Spend $39, Get $5 Off your next order!
Earn
10%
in rewards!
Tall Tails Animated Dog Toy - Trout
Starting at:
$22.99
Spend $39, Get $5 Off your next order!
Earn
10%
in rewards!
HugSmart Ocean Pals 2 in 1 Dog Toy - Clam
Starting at:
$9.97
Spend $39, Get $5 Off your next order!
Clearance
Earn
10%
in rewards!
Gor Pets Reef Collection Plush Dog Toy - Yellow Starfish
Starting at:
$12.99
Spend $39, Get $5 Off your next order!
Sold Out!
Earn
10%
in rewards!
Kittybelles Yellow Tang Plush Fish Cat Toy
Starting at:
$4.99
Spend $39, Get $5 Off your next order!
Top
Sign Up For Our Newsletter!
Sign Up For Our Newsletter!
Submitted!
Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of
website accessibility
Call Us 888-887-0063
Sign In 
Cart 
Get up to 15% Off your 1st Autoship learn more